artifact_id: prefab-myspace
rubric_version: 2.8.0
formula: baseline
judges:
- openai:gpt-5.6-terra
rows:
- criterion_id: DEL-01
  category: delivery
  checker: program
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 10
  points_earned: 10.0
  evidence: ''
  agreement: null
  votes: 0
- criterion_id: DEL-02
  category: delivery
  checker: program
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -4.0
  evidence: 2 console errors
  agreement: null
  votes: 0
- criterion_id: DEL-03
  category: delivery
  checker: program
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: ''
  agreement: null
  votes: 0
- criterion_id: COR-01
  category: correctness
  checker: program
  verdict: na
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: the brief has no reference numbers
  agreement: null
  votes: 0
- criterion_id: BRF-01
  category: answers_brief
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -15.0
  evidence: '"Show most-requested open issues and open issues by assignee" — “Most-requested open issues”
    is present, but no open-issues-by-assignee element is visible.'
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: BRF-02
  category: answers_brief
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Compared the visible requested content (KPIs, requested charts, and requested issue/epic tables)
    with non-brief content such as the welcome header, visitor counter, decorative styling, and spacer/banner
    area.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: WRK-01
  category: working
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed the visible full dashboard and its chart/table panels for page-level errors, loading
    states, or widespread missing data.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: WRK-02
  category: working
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed each visible chart and table panel for blank states, error messages, spinners, or
    placeholders instead of data.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-01
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: cannot_determine
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked the visible area chart and horizontal/vertical bar charts for truncated amount axes.
    The time-series area chart shows a zero baseline; horizontal stacked bar charts have no visible numeric
    value axis and no value labels that allow a reliable baseline comparison.
  agreement: null
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-02
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Compared labels that promise rates/shares/percentages with the displayed values and plotted
    axes.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-03
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Compared repeated color-coded issue-type categories across charts. The legend consistently
    shows Feature in blue, Bug in orange, Task in green, and Other in gray where those categories recur.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-04
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: na
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed visible charts for dual independent value axes and series-to-axis ambiguity.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-05
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: na
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed peer/side-by-side charts for the same measure presented on different unexplained
    scales. The visible charts are distinct measures or single panels rather than comparable same-measure
    small multiples.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: HON-06
  category: honesty
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed line charts for lines connecting unordered categories. The visible line chart, “New
    issues answered within 48 hours,” is ordered by week/date.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-01
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed the forms used for trends, rankings, comparisons, and headline metrics.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-02
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked whether two or more charts use a form that obscures their intended comparisons.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-03
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed multi-series/category charts and their legends, including issue type, triage-age
    bands, area, and adapter charts.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-04
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: 'Checked ordering in ranked categorical displays: the triage queue is oldest-first; areas
    and adapters are displayed largest-to-smallest; epics are ordered by completion; requested issues
    are explicitly ranked by reactions then comments.'
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-05
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed the headline cards and charts for gauges or one-bar charts used only to show a single
    number.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-07
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Compared charts for duplicated datasets shown in the same form.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-08
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -8.0
  evidence: “Opened vs closed per week” — the very large opened bar around late May/early June (about
    450) compresses the other weekly opened/closed bars near the baseline, making their week-to-week comparison
    difficult
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-06
  category: form
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked the starts and ends of the visible time series (“Open issues over time,” “Opened vs
    closed per week,” and “New issues answered within 48 hours”) for abrupt endpoint changes indicating
    an undisclosed partial period.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-01
  category: legibility
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed chart titles, axes, legends, bar labels, and table headers in the full-resolution
    tiles for collisions.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-02
  category: legibility
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed all visible charts for text collisions affecting three or more charts.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-03
  category: legibility
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -4.0
  evidence: 'Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] [VSCE] Prefer parent errors over downstream errors when
    picking..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] [VSCE] double-clicking a model from a local package
    should open..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] Support macros or `generate_database/schema_name`
    in source con..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] Allow for project-specified source field
    descriptions instead o..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] dbt Extension should auto-detect
    git branch to generate the rig..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] VSCE: When hovering over
    something that would work in strict mo..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security] validate SQL
    Injection in `get_columns_batch` via Asymmetri..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security] validate
    SQL Injection via Unescaped ColumnTypeInfo.duckdb_..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security]
    validate SQL Injection in get_columns via Unquoted relation..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT]
    Redshift External OAuth: Support token-based authentication in ..." | Triage queue — oldest first:
    "[Bug] dbt appears to build a schema cache out of all schemas in the pr..." | Triage queue — oldest
    first: "BigQuery: silent jobRateLimitExceeded causes compile freeze on shard-h..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "Expose a Python API with Rust bindings, enabling programmatic invocati..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] BigQuery: nested column descriptions and policy tags are not ..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[FEAT] Support macros or `generate_database/schema_name` in source con..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] dbt-fusion: HTTP client breaks behind corporate SSL inspectio..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[FEAT] Downstream models should inherit results of relevant upstream t..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[BUG] [BigQuery] Partition pseudo-columns included in SELECT * expansi..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[BUG] [BigQuery] Static analyzer rejects valid BigQuery pipe syntax (F..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "BigQuery: show `...GiB processed` annotation in execution logs after c..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] Microbatch models no longer show per-batch start/completion p..."'
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-04
  category: legibility
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Used the full-resolution tiles to inspect small axis ticks, legends, supporting copy, values,
    and table text.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-05
  category: legibility
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Reviewed the visible line, area, column, and stacked-bar charts for marks that cannot be distinguished
    at their drawn size.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-01
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked all headline metrics, chart axes, and table columns for units. Counts are identified
    by their labels; durations use days/hours; percentages use %.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-02
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked chart titles, subtitles, axes, legends, and table headers for raw field names, code,
    or placeholders.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-03
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked the page header for coverage and date information.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-04
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked headline tiles for periods and page-level timing context. The page states “Data as
    of 2026-10-14,” while rolling metrics identify “(28d).”
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-05
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked every visible chart and table for a descriptive title or label.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-07
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Checked visible percentages and their bases. “Answered within 48h (28d)” is contextualized
    by “By week opened; unanswered issues count as misses,” and epic “% DONE” is paired with CLOSED and
    SUB-ISSUES columns.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-08
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Compared visible chart titles, legends, axes, and stated descriptions with their plotted marks.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-09
  category: labeling
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Cross-checked headline values against nearby supporting content and page dates. “Opened /
    closed (28d) 123 / 71” is consistent with “+52 in 28 days,” and the page has one stated as-of date.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-01
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Space between and around cards across the visible page.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-02
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Alignment of KPI cards, chart panels, section headers, and tables.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-04
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -5.0
  evidence: “Triage queue — oldest first” is a very long raw issue table and occupies substantially more
    vertical space than the preceding KPI summary and triage charts
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-05
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: -4.0
  evidence: Neon glowing multicolor card borders and shadows | Repeating star-pattern page background
    | Decorative emoji-heavy section headers
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-06
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Color meaning in charts, including series legends and categorical consistency.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-07
  category: layout
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 0
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Visible page content for placeholders, debug output, test elements, or starter text.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-01
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 10
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Page title, section headings, and the backlog charts for a declarative statement of the main
    finding.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-03
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 3
  points_earned: 3.0
  evidence: “Open issues 511” — “+52 in 28 days”
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-04
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 6
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Charts for annotations, target lines, or a singled-out highlighted point/bar/series marking
    a key event.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-06
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 5
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Chart color treatment for predominantly neutral-gray data with one reserved accent for the
    subject.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-07
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'no'
  points_possible: 4
  points_earned: 0.0
  evidence: Multi-series charts for direct labels on series or slices rather than reliance on legends.
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-08
  category: excellence
  checker: judge
  verdict: 'yes'
  points_possible: 5
  points_earned: 5.0
  evidence: “Open enginev2 issues in dbt-labs/dbt-core (epics excluded unless noted)” | “Open at the end
    of each week, by type” | “Complete weeks; when closed > opened the backlog shrank” | “By week opened;
    unanswered issues count as misses” | “Open issues still labeled status:triage” | “Issues with several
    areas count in each” | “(none) = adapter-agnostic” | “Ranked by reactions, then comments”
  agreement: 1.0
  votes: 1
score: 0.297
category_scores:
  delivery: 0.6
  excellence: 0.242
agreement: 1.0
judge_errors: []
votes:
- criterion_id: BRF-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: '"Show most-requested open issues and open issues by assignee" — “Most-requested open issues”
    is present, but no open-issues-by-assignee element is visible.'
  round: 1
- criterion_id: BRF-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Compared the visible requested content (KPIs, requested charts, and requested issue/epic tables)
    with non-brief content such as the welcome header, visitor counter, decorative styling, and spacer/banner
    area.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: WRK-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed the visible full dashboard and its chart/table panels for page-level errors, loading
    states, or widespread missing data.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: WRK-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed each visible chart and table panel for blank states, error messages, spinners, or
    placeholders instead of data.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: cannot_determine
  evidence: Checked the visible area chart and horizontal/vertical bar charts for truncated amount axes.
    The time-series area chart shows a zero baseline; horizontal stacked bar charts have no visible numeric
    value axis and no value labels that allow a reliable baseline comparison.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Compared labels that promise rates/shares/percentages with the displayed values and plotted
    axes.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-03
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Compared repeated color-coded issue-type categories across charts. The legend consistently
    shows Feature in blue, Bug in orange, Task in green, and Other in gray where those categories recur.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: na
  evidence: Reviewed visible charts for dual independent value axes and series-to-axis ambiguity.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-05
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: na
  evidence: Reviewed peer/side-by-side charts for the same measure presented on different unexplained
    scales. The visible charts are distinct measures or single panels rather than comparable same-measure
    small multiples.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: HON-06
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed line charts for lines connecting unordered categories. The visible line chart, “New
    issues answered within 48 hours,” is ordered by week/date.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed the forms used for trends, rankings, comparisons, and headline metrics.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked whether two or more charts use a form that obscures their intended comparisons.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-03
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed multi-series/category charts and their legends, including issue type, triage-age
    bands, area, and adapter charts.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: 'Checked ordering in ranked categorical displays: the triage queue is oldest-first; areas
    and adapters are displayed largest-to-smallest; epics are ordered by completion; requested issues
    are explicitly ranked by reactions then comments.'
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-05
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed the headline cards and charts for gauges or one-bar charts used only to show a single
    number.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-07
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Compared charts for duplicated datasets shown in the same form.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-08
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: “Opened vs closed per week” — the very large opened bar around late May/early June (about
    450) compresses the other weekly opened/closed bars near the baseline, making their week-to-week comparison
    difficult
  round: 1
- criterion_id: FRM-06
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked the starts and ends of the visible time series (“Open issues over time,” “Opened vs
    closed per week,” and “New issues answered within 48 hours”) for abrupt endpoint changes indicating
    an undisclosed partial period.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed chart titles, axes, legends, bar labels, and table headers in the full-resolution
    tiles for collisions.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed all visible charts for text collisions affecting three or more charts.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-03
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: 'Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] [VSCE] Prefer parent errors over downstream errors when
    picking..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] [VSCE] double-clicking a model from a local package
    should open..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] Support macros or `generate_database/schema_name`
    in source con..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] Allow for project-specified source field
    descriptions instead o..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] dbt Extension should auto-detect
    git branch to generate the rig..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT] VSCE: When hovering over
    something that would work in strict mo..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security] validate SQL
    Injection in `get_columns_batch` via Asymmetri..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security] validate
    SQL Injection via Unescaped ColumnTypeInfo.duckdb_..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[security]
    validate SQL Injection in get_columns via Unquoted relation..." | Triage queue — oldest first: "[FEAT]
    Redshift External OAuth: Support token-based authentication in ..." | Triage queue — oldest first:
    "[Bug] dbt appears to build a schema cache out of all schemas in the pr..." | Triage queue — oldest
    first: "BigQuery: silent jobRateLimitExceeded causes compile freeze on shard-h..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "Expose a Python API with Rust bindings, enabling programmatic invocati..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] BigQuery: nested column descriptions and policy tags are not ..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[FEAT] Support macros or `generate_database/schema_name` in source con..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] dbt-fusion: HTTP client breaks behind corporate SSL inspectio..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[FEAT] Downstream models should inherit results of relevant upstream t..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[BUG] [BigQuery] Partition pseudo-columns included in SELECT * expansi..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[BUG] [BigQuery] Static analyzer rejects valid BigQuery pipe syntax (F..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "BigQuery: show `...GiB processed` annotation in execution logs after c..." | Most-requested
    open issues: "[v2 Bug] Microbatch models no longer show per-batch start/completion p..."'
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Used the full-resolution tiles to inspect small axis ticks, legends, supporting copy, values,
    and table text.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LEG-05
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Reviewed the visible line, area, column, and stacked-bar charts for marks that cannot be distinguished
    at their drawn size.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked all headline metrics, chart axes, and table columns for units. Counts are identified
    by their labels; durations use days/hours; percentages use %.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked chart titles, subtitles, axes, legends, and table headers for raw field names, code,
    or placeholders.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-03
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked the page header for coverage and date information.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked headline tiles for periods and page-level timing context. The page states “Data as
    of 2026-10-14,” while rolling metrics identify “(28d).”
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-05
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked every visible chart and table for a descriptive title or label.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-07
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Checked visible percentages and their bases. “Answered within 48h (28d)” is contextualized
    by “By week opened; unanswered issues count as misses,” and epic “% DONE” is paired with CLOSED and
    SUB-ISSUES columns.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-08
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Compared visible chart titles, legends, axes, and stated descriptions with their plotted marks.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LBL-09
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Cross-checked headline values against nearby supporting content and page dates. “Opened /
    closed (28d) 123 / 71” is consistent with “+52 in 28 days,” and the page has one stated as-of date.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Space between and around cards across the visible page.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-02
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Alignment of KPI cards, chart panels, section headers, and tables.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: “Triage queue — oldest first” is a very long raw issue table and occupies substantially more
    vertical space than the preceding KPI summary and triage charts
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-05
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: Neon glowing multicolor card borders and shadows | Repeating star-pattern page background
    | Decorative emoji-heavy section headers
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-06
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Color meaning in charts, including series legends and categorical consistency.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: LAY-07
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Visible page content for placeholders, debug output, test elements, or starter text.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-01
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Page title, section headings, and the backlog charts for a declarative statement of the main
    finding.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-03
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: “Open issues 511” — “+52 in 28 days”
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-04
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Charts for annotations, target lines, or a singled-out highlighted point/bar/series marking
    a key event.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-06
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Chart color treatment for predominantly neutral-gray data with one reserved accent for the
    subject.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-07
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'no'
  evidence: Multi-series charts for direct labels on series or slices rather than reliance on legends.
  round: 1
- criterion_id: EXC-08
  judge: gpt-5.6-terra
  sample: 0
  verdict: 'yes'
  evidence: “Open enginev2 issues in dbt-labs/dbt-core (epics excluded unless noted)” | “Open at the end
    of each week, by type” | “Complete weeks; when closed > opened the backlog shrank” | “By week opened;
    unanswered issues count as misses” | “Open issues still labeled status:triage” | “Issues with several
    areas count in each” | “(none) = adapter-agnostic” | “Ranked by reactions, then comments”
  round: 1